| Aurora | 2021 | Paz Fabrega (director and screenwriter) with Rebeca Woodbridge and Raquel Villalobos |
One day, when Luisa was in the school bathroom, washing clay off her hands, she heard someone going sick in one of the stalls. It was a teenager, Yuliana, a girl she recognized as the older sister of one of her students. On the floor, by the sinks, the girl had dropped a pill blister pack. Luisa recognized the drugs. The girl was trying to provoke an abortion.
LUISA:
“Are you well? You should get checked because… Because if you were vomiting, you may have vomited the pills…”
YULIANA:
“I was told to wait 12 hours before going to a hospital”
LUISA:
“I wouldn’t take you to a hospital”
This was the beginning of the unlikely friendship between these two characters.
Luisa took Yuliana to a doctor she trusted, and the doctor determined that Yuli was indeed pregnant - not in the first few weeks of pregnancy, as the girl thought, but rather, in her 5th month. Too late, she said, for the pills to have any effect. Too late for anything other than hard choices.
Yuli is seventeen years old. Abortions are illegal in Costa Rica. Her mother doesn’t know about it and Yuli doesn’t want her to. None of her friends know. No one, except Luisa. And Luisa offers to help.
This movie could have been obvious in so many ways… It could have given Luisa a tragic backstory. It could have painted her as a woman who always wanted a daughter, but couldn’t have one. It could have shown her as a young girl, decades earlier, facing the same difficulties Yuliana is facing and offering her, in the present, the help she didn’t have back then. These things would have been obvious. Instead, the movie gives no explanation behind the reason why this successful, mature and independent architect would want to take a young girl like Yuli under her protection. It’s enough that she does.
Their relationship takes many forms. At times, Luisa is a friend, the only friend Yuli can talk to, a “girl” with whom she can hang out, laugh or go dancing on the beach. At other times, Luisa becomes a mother figure who accompanies Yuli on her doctor’s appointments and offers the girl advice, from the perspective of an older, more experienced woman. She does show, however, a degree of respect for Yuli’s individuality that’s uncharacteristic of any parent, and at times like this, she is more like an older sister, patiently listening to her little sister’s thoughts, recognizing, as the more mature of the two, that the younger one needs help, catching her when she falls and quietly supporting her in all of her decisions. She advises Yuli to tell her mother about the pregnancy but respects the girl’s decision to stay quiet.
When Yuli starts to show, it is Luisa who dissuades her from running away. The girl was waiting for her, on the front steps, when she came home from the construction site. She smiled and let her in, sitting across from Yuli while she told her of her plan to disappear. "May I touch it?" she asked, placing a hand on the girl's belly when she got closer, astounded at how much bigger she was, barely showing through her blouse, but much more so than when they last spoke. And she moved to sit by Yuli's side when she asked the girl to reconsider that plan. She did more than that: she gave Yuli keys, offering her house as sanctuary. And later Yuli tried on her clothes, while Luisa helped her choose which ones hid her bump better.
I realize now that my description of their friendship makes the whole thing sounds a bit unrealistic. But it’s not like they were characters isolated in a fairy tale land that allowed for such an unlikely bond to form. Not at all. When Luisa’s boyfriend came home for an unexpected visit, Yuli’s constant presence in her apartment proved to be a disruption, as it would have been in reality, but again, there was no melodrama. Luisa chose that arrangement, there was no room for obvious arguments. It was as simple as that. Yuli’s mother was not a monster, and her friends seemed like a great bunch of people. She had options. But she needed Luisa. They fitted together. Once they found each other, there was no letting go.
It would be a mistake to say that this movie is just a story without context. There are layers of commentary on real world issues, such as the lack of reproductive freedom for women in Latin American countries. But the movie is not about reproductive rights, any more than it is about teen pregnancy. All of this is subtext and set-up, it never feels forced or preachy, and the opinions of the writer, whatever they are, never push the story to the background. There is a clash between Yuliana’s family’s conservative views and Luisa’s progressive and worldly attitude. Yuli’s family, if they knew, would rather her give up on school to raise the baby rather than any other alternative. Luisa on the other hand, has a more progressive and worldly view. She worries about the girl being trapped in a future of limited possibilities and she is the one who introduces the idea of adoption. This clash, however, is never more important than the bond between Luisa and Yuli, and the ending, however hushed it seemed to me (I would have liked a little more) makes this abundantly clear.
If I have to highlight one negative aspect of this piece it would be the casting of the younger protagonist. Through her actions and dialogue, Yuli was never more than “the pregnant teenager”, and I really wish the character had become more interesting than that… Her eyes were always a bit empty, she never had much to say, and even her body language didn't mean much (apart from moments like that when she first went to Luisa's house, clutching the edges of her shorts). Perhaps it’s the way the character was written, but I wish she’d been more expressive, as she would have made a better counterpart for Luisa’s character. It would have elevated the movie, and added so much to the chemistry between the protagonists!
Luisa, on the other hand, was great… On the construction site, talking to the engineers, she was a confident and capable professional. On the floor of her apartment, alone, she was the insecure, troubled artist, struggling to finish a choreography for music that only she could hear. With the kids in her class, she was the inspiring, whimsical art teacher, with paint stains on her clothes and fragments of clay on her hair. And yet, these aspects of her personality never felt disjointed or forced… Instead, they seemed real… Characters in stories are often oversimplified. They fall into stereotypes: “the career woman”, “the sensitive pre-school teacher”, “the failed artist”... It’s like in stories, nobody wants to be more than one thing. Luisa felt like a real person, with multitudes inside her.
She was my favourite character in this movie. To me, it seemed like she had something true inside her, something she was trying to put out, to express artistically through her designs, her classes, her choreography… Her outlet, however, came in the unexpected sisterhood with Yuliana. In that relationship, all the aspects of Luisa came together. She was mature, kind, patient and loving. More than anything, however, she exuded warmth, and the little ways in which she expressed this made Aurora a delightful movie to watch. Like when she placed her hand lightly on Yuli's back, before taking her to the doctor for the first time, or how she looked at the girl, trying to understand what was in her mind, patiently waiting for Yuli to tell her, in her own time. It was a beautiful exploration of female friendship, of intergenerational friendship, and integrates a group of stories I am more and more interested in experiencing.
| Luisa had a vulnerability to her, and yet, it didn't detract from her maturity... I don't think I have seen this unusual mix of traits in a character of her age... It was beautiful to watch. |
All things considered, I really enjoyed this movie. It was slow-paced, perhaps too slow at times, but it was exactly the type of character-driven story I was looking forward to when this year’s festival started. I had never seen a movie from Costa Rica, and I would definitely check out the director’s other pieces in the future. Do I recommend it to others? I don’t know… It’s a matter of personal taste in movies… I would watch it a second time in the future though, and that, I believe, says a lot…